Broadway Utica
HomeColumnsCassandra Harris-LockwoodBad Guys Don’t Like Dogs   

Bad Guys Don’t Like Dogs   

by C. Harris-Lockwood  editor-in-chief


Editor’s Note:Originally printed in 2018, sadly this issue continues to haunt our nation today thus it is being reprinted for more attention. I came up with this idea years ago and finally wrote it up. I’d love to see a campaign to train Guardian Dogs in schools develop. CHL


To the tune of the Friendly Beasts:


“I,” said the dog all black and white.

“I guarded the manger all through the night.”

“I guarded the Babe ‘til the morning light”

“I,” said the dog all black and white.”        


  Wayne LaPierre, spokesman of the NRA claims that the only effective response to, “a bad guy with a gun is a good guy with a gun.” Well, Rin Tin Tin, Lassie and the Dutch Malinois dog that assisted in the takedown of Osama bin Laden vigorously object.

For centuries Man has employed dogs for service, knowing that in every way the dog’s running speed and reflex response time, strength, senses of smell, hearing and sight, and are superior to Man’s. And that ultimately, a dog will lay down its life to do its job.

  And bad guys don’t like dogs, especially highly trained ones capable of covering a distance of 30 feet in less than one second.

Had Sandy Hook Principal Dawn Hochsprung been able to send out her school’s well trained Guardian Dog to fend off shooter, Adam Lanza, she may still have been here to tell the story.

  The recent Newtown Massacre may have had a completely different outcome had the envisioned new category of K-9 protectors, the School Guardian Dog, been at hand. Trained to accept and protect children, the dog, at the very least would have taken a bullet for Hochsprung. The valiant, yet slain educator may have had an extra moment to retreat into the inner office and call 911 alerting police that an armed assailant had forcefully entered the school.

  Or perhaps, said Guradian Dog would have taken down the shooter and prevented the entire event from occurring. Lanza wore a bullet proof vest. Lanza would not have been prepared for the 330 pounds per square inch of jaw power delivered with precision and without hesitation, to his unprotected arm.

 And speaking to La Pierre’s assertion that only a ‘good guy with a gun’ is the answer, Bad Guys Don’t Like dogs and dogs don’t like bad guys. There is a primordial fear of a snarling wolf-like animal in the human gene pool, understood even by the mentally ill.

  Add to that the threat of the focused intent of a 75 pound beast trained to ignore pain and distractions, that can leap 5 foot obstacles, can run at speeds exceeding 30 miles per hour, is trained to use the full force of his body to knock down a human target, will attack with a full mouth bite and not let go; the power and ferocity only a dog can deliver is respected and feared.

  Dog Trainer, Sal Piazza, recalls working with the Columbus, Ohio Police Department in pursuit of a bad guy with a gun. The armed perpetrator ended up on the 2nd floor. When the K-9 came onto the scene the bad guy jumped out of the window rather than face or shoot the dog. He ended up with two broken legs and explained to police that he jumped out of the window because he, “didn’t want to be bitten by the dog.”

  Owner operator of Piazza’s Professional Dog Training School/K-9 Services Unlimited, Sal Piazza thinks placement of Guardian Dogs in schools is a “good idea.” Running the oldest dog training school in the area, Piazza says. “It is a non-lethal  method of dealing with adverse, even deadly situations.

   Piazza says he approached former Superintendent of Utica Schools, Dan Lowengard about putting dogs in schools back in  the 80’s. “Things weren’t the way they are now. It was a different back then,” said Piazza.

   Piazza explains that dogs are generally trained for use as either Guard Dogs for personal protection or for offensive training and other police work such as cadaver, bomb or drug sniffing. This new category of dog assistant would be trained with a dual purpose ability. 

  These dogs would be chosen for their    acceptance of children and trained to not only for personal protection and for guarding the children and staff in the school area but offensive training as well.

  “We condition the dog for different circumstances and jobs. These dogs are trained with blanks so that they are not fearful of guns being fired. They will go after the guy and take him down. Then there is time to call for 911 or lock down the premises.  These dogs would be a benefit in schools.”

  “In close proximity the dog is trained to hit the assailant with the force of its body, to hit and bite and hold. Once a man is down it’s hard, almost impossible to fight a dog. The dog is then given the command stop and hold. The assailant is told to stop fighting the dog.

  “If the guy gives up the dog is trained to use the minimum force. He barks if the guy makes another move. The dog does not need another command. The man is then his prey and the dog will automatically go after the man should he flee. Once that happens the dog is taught that there is mothering to fear. If he does move the dog will take him out. The dog will fight to the end.

  “The suspect is thinking about being bitten by the dog again and nobody wants to be bitten by a dog,” says Piazza.

  Consider this, had a good guy with a gun come onto the scene where Lanza was shooting children, Lanza would have likely been standing between the children and the ‘good guy with the gun,’ putting the children directly in the line of fire. If the good guy’s bullet were to go astray, more innocents would have been at risk.

Had a dog been sent instead, Lanza’s fate would have been swiftly and precisely delivered. Trained Guard Dog’s don’t miss the target, delivering upwards of 200 pounds per square inch of bite by the lithe and energetic Malinois to over 500 ppi by the Mastiff. And these dogs don’t miss their targets.

  Calls for an armed police officer in every school is excessive, both in manpower costs and in fearful presence. This new option for school security should incorporate an already existing member of school personnel as hander of the Guardian Dog.

  This individual would be trained   with the dog and responsible for it. The dog would accompany the handler home and be a part of the family when school is not in session providing even more of a bond between handler and dog.

  Although there would be a cost to the acquisition and care of a highly trained dog, there would be no additional costs to the school in terms of added personnel salary, benefits or retirement packages, certainly a consideration in this day and age.

  So, while the national debate rages over gun control, adding armed police officers to schools or arming and training teachers and administrators, there are trained dogs returning from duty overseas, there are dogs in shelters and pounds, there are dogs currently in training awaiting placement. Any and all of these dogs can be properly trained, selected and placed into schools for protecting our school children, teachers and administrators as Guardian Dogs. It could begin tomorrow.

  Local Dog Trainer and Consultant to the Steven Swann Humane Society, Joe Nuccio, thinks it is a great idea as well but stresses the importance of some high ranking official to champion the cause.  “Of course, liability issues might come into play, and these dogs aren’t cheap. The handler would have to have at least two months of training to work with the dog and take it home with them, but a dog is a lot cheaper than a police officer.

  “And we’re not just talking about Shepherds here. We’re talking about dogs.  Shepherds flunk out of training every day. It’s not every dog that can do this work. Some Pitt Bulls would be gentle enough with children yet be excellent at guarding and protecting. This is a good idea. An excellent idea, but you still need the champion to make it happen.”

  As President Obama said in his address to the nation after the Sandy Hook Elementary School Massacre, “We can’t tolerate this anymore. These tragedies must end. And to end them, we must change. We will be told that the causes of such violence are complex, and that is true. No single law – no set of laws can eliminate evil from the world, or prevent every senseless act of violence in our society.

  “But that can’t be an excuse for inaction. Surely, we can do better than this. If there is even one step we can take to save another child, or another parent, or another town, from the grief that has visited Tucson, and Aurora, and Oak Creek, and Newtown, and communities from Columbine to Blacksburg before that – then surely we have an obligation to try.”

  Surely, the reasoned and skilled use of ‘Man’s best friend” as Guardian Dogs can be one of those steps in solving this complex national problem.


Utica Phoenix Staff
Utica Phoenix Staff
The Utica Phoenix is a publication of For The Good, Inc., a 501 (c) (3) in Utica, NY. The Phoenix is an independent newsmagazine covering local news, state news, community events, and more. Follow us on Twitter and Facebook, and also check out Utica Phoenix Radio at 95.5 FM/1550 AM, complete with Urban hits, morning talk shows, live DJs, and more.

Most Popular