Broadway Utica
HomeCommunity VoicePlaying that Law and Order Game- By George Kuchma

Playing that Law and Order Game- By George Kuchma

Many a joke carries a rich truth that gets your attention. Here’s one you may not have heard: How many cops does it take to throw a handcuffed suspect down a flight of stairs? Answer: None, “He fell.”

Fortunately, this story is not about trigger-happy-policing or excessive use of force, there is enough of that in the news of late. The focus here is more about unjust prosecution.

It is understood that the police are subject to the same emotional triggers that affect us all. A bad attitude can bring out the worst in an officer just like a bad approach by a cop can trigger belligerence in a citizen. This story relates the calamity of a UPD traffic stop gone bad, the subsequent malicious prosecution and the continuing aftermath.

Missteps were taken by all involved in this matter but, it is important to remember; citizens may occasionally run afoul of the law for which they are held accountable. But law enforcement personnel and officers of the court are held to a much higher standard.

There are oaths of office administered to these well-paid professionals. Police duties put them in peril on a daily basis but theirs is a sacred trust to serve and protect.  The District Attorney is an elected office, and bar exams qualify them and other attorneys for their respective and respected positions. Let us keep this in mind as we review the facts:

  • In 2009, police observed Nassau County resident Vladimir Jeanty in a rental car on the streets of Utica, ‘driving while being Black.’ A standard traffic stop was executed.
  • In plain sight were several cell phones, some broken. The stop occurred on Park Ave, a “drug related area” (where in Utica is not?) Adds up to probable cause?
  • During the curb side interrogation, the verbal exchange became heated; Vlad got hot under the collar, the officer was hot for a collar. Vlad was told he ran a stop sign he is sure he obeyed.
  • Officer not so friendly had enough and called for backup.
  • Vlad’s instincts kicked in; fight or flight. He split that curb scene on foot, headed for Oneida Sq., and the chase was on.
  • Highlights of the ensuing foot pursuit include a fence to roof hopping and impressive feats of physical prowess by both parties.
  • To the UPD’s credit, Vlad told this reporter the takedown and cuff-up were clean; no low blows or kidney punches. Just a stand-up firm cuff-up. Thank you, gentlemen, with utmost sincerity and respect.
  • Vladimir was arrested, tried, and convicted for possession of cocaine that did not exist. He served 2.5 years Upstate and was released in August of 2012, having served the maximum term of the sentence.
  • While locked up, Vlad studied and absorbed the ins and outs of criminal procedure law.

Upon his release, representing himself (a pro se litigant) Vlad litigated a successful appeal. His conviction was vacated in 2015. This is worth noting for it is no small feat.

The UPD and DA applied the usual tactics; overbook and overcharge the suspect, keep the bail amount excessive, offer a plea deal to avoid trial and state time.

Vlad played the gambit, sacrificing 2.5 years of his life to the State to prevail upon appeal. This is no minor victory, this is the story of a judicial hero, a brilliant and persevering, high school educated minority citizen standing up the full arsenal of the Oneida County DA’s office and prevailing. Well done Vladimir Jeanty, you stand among the judicial exemplars that have shaped American Law.

In a chess game white always gets the first move. In this case, the first game ended in a draw. In April 2016 the board was set up again, this time Vlad has white and made the first move.

He filed a claim with the Court of claims. In August that year, he filed a civil rights complaint in Federal Court against The City of Utica, Chief Mark Williams, Lt. Sean Dougherty, Inv. Peter Paladino, Pfc. Michael Cerminaro,  DA Scott McNamara, ADA Grant Garramone, ADA Steven Cox and Several John Does.

On August 18, 2017, the Hon. Brenda K. Sannes, United States District Judge ruled on motions filed on behalf of the above-named defendants. Some motions were granted others dismissed.

Representing the defense are; Zachary C. Oren, Assistant Corporation Counsel, City of Utica. The law firm of Schmitt & Lascurettes, LLC for defendants Hon. Scott D. McNamara and the County of Oneida.

In chess parlance the above-named attorneys are Expert and Master level players. Their opponent Vlad is an unrated Novice. At this point in the game white (Vlad) has a strong advantage.

His pieces are well developed and he holds a material advantage. As this goes to press; Vlad is awaiting discovery materials before he makes his next move.

Of concern to Oneida County residents is the cost. Several knowledgeable individuals estimate the cost to the City and County to defend such a suit has already topped $100,000.  A settlement offer is expected soon to be seen on the table in this matter.

As the endgame plays out the Phoenix will remain in contact with Vlad and report if black resigns.

George Kuchma is a chess player, writer, community volunteer and activist. Born and reared in Little Falls, now making his home in Utica, NY. Comments on this story can be sent by email:

Utica Phoenix Staff
Utica Phoenix Staff
The Utica Phoenix is a publication of For The Good, Inc., a 501 (c) (3) in Utica, NY. The Phoenix is an independent newsmagazine covering local news, state news, community events, and more. Follow us on Twitter and Facebook, and also check out Utica Phoenix Radio at 95.5 FM/1550 AM, complete with Urban hits, morning talk shows, live DJs, and more.

Most Popular