HomeCommunity EventArts & TheaterThe Castle II - A Theatrical Review

The Castle II – A Theatrical Review

THE CASTLE II – A THEATRICAL REVIEW

By Natalie Williams

I attended a performance of “The Castle II” on November 14, 2026 in Manhattan. There are plenty of theater performance to choose from in New York City.  This one was quite different. “Castle II” is a theatrical performance in which four formerly incarcerated people describe what happened to have brought them to be sentenced and land in prison – often for lengthy terms. Four people recounted their lives; taking turns describing their experiences before and during incarceration, and their transition back into society after their time had been served.

The show was conceived of and directed by David Rothenberg; founder of the Fortune Society. The original performance of The Castle; with a different group of speakers, had received rave reviews on it’s previous Off – Broadway run. The Castle II was interesting. Three men and one woman, uttered their tales; reflecting on what a difference a second chance can make in a person’s life.  Their gratitude for the opportunity was evident.

These narratives were reflective of the story of how “The Castle”; the building itself – had transformed through time. The impressive gray stone structure on 140th Street and Riverside Drive made it’s transition from a former church, to a girl’s school, to a Yeshiva, and then became neglected. In time, it became a vacant and physically decayed building, which turned into a “crack house” [ a place where illegal drugs are sold and user’s congregate ]. The stone building was later renovated to become a Fortune Society training Institute with an accompanying housing unit which serves to assist the former felons – with obtaining jobs, and housing, –  as they are returned to communities.

The Castle building’s physical decline and ultimate renovation and re-purposed rise to become a facility in the community providing useful; some say life-saving service to former felons is a figurative example of the transformation which had occurred in the lives of the people that the Fortune Society has served.

The four people in the theatrical presentation say: “We told you who we were, and who we have become; but we are unfinished projects.”

They then proceed to introduce themselves and take turns describing their experiences, regrets and revelations.

They told varied tales of their upbringing; experiences of poverty, hunger, & violence, education – or lack thereof, drug use, theft, crimes, fragmented relationships with their families and experiences with ‘the system’.

Of four the people speaking; two of them where black men, with one white (or possibly hispanic) man, and a hispanic woman. As our nation’s and the New York State prisons are full of a disproportionally high number of people from “minority’ groups, this is representative of the real statistics.

During the question and answer portion, at the close of the performance; many in the audience complimented the four people for their honesty and bravery in the stark telling of their stories. I noted that no detailed descriptions of the crimes that they had committed was made, nor were the consequences of their actions on their victims addressed.

Mr. Rothenberg pointed out that “99 percent of the people who go to prison are ultimately returned to society”.  He created an organization to compassionately provide them with what they needed; a place to stay, assistance in getting training in a job, and the opportunity to “renovate’’ themselves.

The Castle II Is available for touring and educational performances. For more information; please contact drothenberg@fortunesociety.org

Most Popular