At a packed Utica forum, Sanders says lasting change will take political power, broad coalitions and a willingness to confront hard questions.
By Michelle Laguerre
UTICA, N.Y. — New York State Sen. James Sanders Jr. turned a packed community forum Friday evening into a call for unity, challenging reparations supporters to move beyond disagreement and assemble the political strength needed to win meaningful remedies.
Speaking November 20 at the Carol L. Crooms BECA Center Café, 1105 Park Avenue, Sanders drew on his family history, legislative experience and exchanges with audience members to argue that justice requires both a moral case and a workable political strategy.
Courtney Muhammad, founder of the center, introduced Sanders as a “political pit bull,” a fitting description for the senator who helped advance New York’s landmark reparations-commission legislation. Sanders arrived following an afternoon minority- and women-owned business enterprise (MWBE) workshop at the Utica Public Library.
The senator described himself as the son of a sharecropper. His father, he told the audience, had been pulled from school in third grade, while his mother’s schooling ended in fifth grade. Their experience made the legacy of exclusion deeply personal. “I come from the bottom,” Sanders said, contrasting those beginnings with his path to public office.
Sanders sponsored the 2023 legislation that created the New York State Community Commission on Reparations Remedies. Signed by Gov. Kathy Hochul on December 19, 2023, the law established a body to study the legacy of slavery and discriminatory policies and recommend remedies. It did not itself authorize reparations payments.
Much of the evening focused on a politically difficult question: who should qualify for reparations? As audience members raised competing views, Sanders warned that defining eligibility so narrowly that supporters splinter into rival camps could undermine the very votes needed to advance legislation. He posed a pointed question: “If I can’t get Blacks as a base, can I win this argument?” His answer: “I don’t think so.”
“My job is to win,” Sanders said, emphasizing that broad support must be built among Black lawmakers and beyond. His argument did not erase disagreements over lineage, eligibility or what genuine repair should include; it underscored the need to debate those issues without sacrificing collective political leverage.

The exchange also touched on the spiritual meaning of repair. One participant argued that the damage of slavery and subsequent injustice cannot be fully healed through government action alone. The discussion illustrated the range of views in the room, even as participants shared an urgency to address enduring harms.
Sanders invoked Malcolm X and Fannie Lou Hamer, repeating a line he attributed to Hamer: “I may fall, but I will fall leaning forward, not moving backwards.” From the sharecropping fields of his parents’ generation to the floor of the State Senate, the through line of his remarks was clear: building a winning movement requires organizing, persistence and unity, not simply agreement that reparations are overdue.