HomeLocal NewsUtica Council Rejects Good Cause Eviction Law 5–4 After Emotional Tenant Pleas

Utica Council Rejects Good Cause Eviction Law 5–4 After Emotional Tenant Pleas

By Michelle Laguerre

UTICA, N.Y., Nov. 19, 2026 — Following months of debate and organizing by tenants and housing advocates, the Utica Common Council rejected a proposal to adopt New York’s Good Cause Eviction protections on Wednesday, Nov. 18, by a narrow 5–4 vote. The decision followed a Citizen Action of New York rally outside City Hall and nearly 45 minutes of public comment from tenants, advocates and landlords.

Voting in favor were First Ward Councilor Katie Aiello, Fifth Ward Councilor Venice Ervin, and Councilors-at-Large Heather Wasielewski and Jack LoMedico.

Voting against were Second Ward Councilor Robert Burmaster, Third Ward Councilor Joseph Betar, Fourth Ward Councilor Frank Carcone, Sixth Ward Councilor Joseph Betrus and Councilor-at-Large Samantha Colosimo-Testa.

One of the evening’s most troubling accounts came from Jan, a South Utica resident who described an ongoing dispute with her landlord over repairs and serious health concerns she attributed to mold in her home.

“You’ve all been listening to each other. Now I want you to listen to reality,” Jan urged the council. She said she had appeared in City Court that morning in connection with her landlord’s alleged failure to meet repair obligations. “I am dying from mold inhalation poisoning,” she told council members, describing what she said a doctor had told her. Her medical claims and allegations against the landlord were not independently verified.

Jan’s Third Ward council representative, Joseph Betar, voted against the legislation. Betar said that more than 4,300 housing units in Utica already have other housing protections and would be exempt from Good Cause. He argued that city resources should instead focus on stronger housing-code enforcement, accountability for unresolved property violations and lead-abatement efforts.

Senya Bekui, Lead Organizer for the Central New York chapter of Citizen Action of New York, had pressed for passage of the measure, including during a Nov. 17 appearance on WUTQ’s Talk of the Town. Bekui and fellow advocates described the measure as an additional safeguard against displacement for tenants who meet their rental obligations. Shana Dahlin, Board President of Citizen Action of New York, has also been involved in the organization’s housing advocacy.

Sixth Ward Councilor Joseph Betrus, who voted no, said he considered the measure redundant and burdensome for landlords. “The law is basically already in existence,” he said, explaining that he had listened to people on both sides of the debate. Landlords who spoke against the proposal raised concerns about rising costs, eviction expenses and the impact of additional regulations on responsible property owners.

Aiello, who supported the proposal, argued that the debate had obscured what Good Cause actually does. Nonpayment of rent and serious lease violations would remain legally recognized grounds for eviction. Under New York’s 2024 law, municipalities outside New York City may opt in to protections for covered tenants against eviction or nonrenewal without a legally recognized reason, with procedures to challenge certain excessive rent increases.

The city initially voted to schedule an additional public hearing. Colosimo-Testa then successfully moved to bring the proposal out of committee for an immediate vote. After the 5–4 defeat, the hearing was canceled.

Jan’s testimony brought the consequences of unsafe rental conditions into sharp focus, although Good Cause itself is primarily an eviction and lease-renewal measure rather than a replacement for building-code enforcement. With the proposal defeated, questions remain about how the city will address housing conditions, affordability and tenant stability — and what actions council members will take next.

Most Popular