By David LaGuerre –
The Disturbing Alliance of Two Strongmen
I am outraged and deeply disappointed by the blatant disregard for our judicial system displayed during Monday’s meeting between former President Trump and El Salvador’s President Nayib Bukele. What we witnessed wasn’t merely a diplomatic exchange, but a public celebration of authoritarianism that spits in the face of America’s separation of powers.
The case of Kilmar Armando Abrego Garcia stands as a damning indictment of this administration’s willingness to twist facts and flout the highest court in our land. This Maryland resident was wrongfully deported to El Salvador despite having clear legal protections against removal – and now, despite a Supreme Court order demanding his return, both leaders have openly refused to comply.
This isn’t just bureaucratic foot-dragging; it’s an assault on the very foundations of our democracy.
The Abrego Garcia Travesty: Facts vs. Fiction
The facts of this case are crystal clear, though you wouldn’t know it from the administration’s deliberate mischaracterizations. Abrego Garcia lived in the United States for 14 years, working in construction and raising three children with disabilities. He had been granted “withholding of removal” – a legal protection specifically prohibiting his deportation to El Salvador due to the documented risks of persecution he faced there.
Despite having no criminal convictions, Abrego Garcia was deported in what the Department of Justice later admitted was an “administrative error.” But rather than correcting this grave injustice, the administration has doubled down, making unsubstantiated claims that he belongs to MS-13 – claims never proven in court and contradicted by the fact that an immigration judge had already determined he posed no danger to the United States.
It’s shameful that the administration continues to smear a man who has already been grievously wronged by our system. Even more disturbing is President Bukele’s statement that returning Abrego Garcia would be “smuggling a terrorist into the United States,” despite the complete absence of evidence to support such inflammatory rhetoric.
A Pattern of Authoritarian Governance
This case is not an isolated incident but part of a disturbing pattern. Both Trump and Bukele have consistently shown contempt for legal norms and democratic institutions:
-
Judicial Independence Under Attack: Trump has repeatedly undermined the judiciary, attacking judges who rule against his interests and seeking to install loyalists in key positions.
-
Executive Overreach: Both leaders have bypassed legislative bodies through executive orders and emergency declarations to implement controversial policies.
-
Mass Incarceration: Bukele’s state of emergency has led to the detention of over 72,000 Salvadorans without due process – a model Trump openly admires and seeks to emulate.
-
Dehumanizing Rhetoric: Both leaders use language that strips migrants and political opponents of their humanity, creating an environment where rights violations become acceptable.
I am particularly disturbed by the financial arrangement revealed during the meeting: the U.S. has agreed to pay El Salvador $6 million to imprison deportees for a year. This commodification of human beings transforms our immigration system into a profit-centered enterprise with no regard for human rights or due process.
The Supreme Court Defied
The most alarming aspect of this case is the open defiance of a Supreme Court order. Our highest court specifically directed the administration to facilitate Abrego Garcia’s return to the United States. Instead, we witnessed both presidents publicly refusing to comply, with President Bukele stating he “cannot” return Abrego Garcia despite having absolute authority to do so.
This is not a matter of interpretation or bureaucratic complexity – it is a direct challenge to the constitutional separation of powers that has protected American democracy for nearly 250 years. When political leaders can simply ignore court orders they dislike, we have crossed a dangerous threshold into authoritarian governance.
The Human Cost Behind the Politics
Lost in the political posturing is the profound human suffering this case represents. Abrego Garcia remains imprisoned in CECOT, El Salvador’s notorious maximum-security prison, despite having committed no crime. His family in Maryland continues to struggle without his support, including three children with disabilities who depend on him.
This callous disregard for human dignity extends to thousands of others caught in similar circumstances – people deported without due process, families separated, and lives destroyed through “administrative errors” that the government refuses to correct.
Defending Democracy Requires Action
This flagrant disrespect for judicial authority demands a response from all who value democracy:
-
Congressional Oversight: Congress must immediately investigate this violation of the separation of powers and hold accountable those responsible for defying the Supreme Court.
-
Legal Challenges: Civil rights organizations should continue pressing for enforcement of the court order through additional legal actions.
-
Public Pressure: Citizens must demand respect for judicial independence and the rule of law through calls to representatives, public demonstrations, and at the ballot box.
-
Media Scrutiny: Journalists must continue to highlight this dangerous precedent and refuse to accept the administration’s mischaracterizations.
Democracy at a Crossroads
The Trump-Bukele alliance represents a dangerous convergence of authoritarian tendencies that threatens the foundation of our democratic system. When leaders can openly defy our highest court without consequence, we have begun a dangerous slide toward rule by executive fiat rather than rule of law.
I am deeply troubled that we find ourselves at this crossroads. The strength of American democracy has always rested on our commitment to checks and balances, the peaceful transfer of power, and respect for judicial authority. All three are now under direct assault.
We cannot allow judicial independence to be sacrificed on the altar of political expediency. The case of Kilmar Armando Abrego Garcia must become a rallying cry for defending the rule of law – not just for his sake, but for the preservation of American democracy itself.
