HomeBlack PerspectiveOpinion: NFL Race-Norming Deal Must Deliver for Black Players

Opinion: NFL Race-Norming Deal Must Deliver for Black Players

Opinion | By David LaGuerre

The NFL disability race-norming settlement deserves attention beyond the sports page. As a 65-year-old Black publisher, I see a basic question of dignity in this case: When a person asks for help, does the system see that person clearly, or does it start with a racial assumption?

A change in the rules can matter a great deal. But the people affected need more than a statement that the process is now fair. They need a careful review of what happened before, clear answers about their claims and the benefits they qualify to receive.

That is the standard I would use to judge this settlement.

What changed last week

A federal judge in Maryland approved a settlement over race-based adjustments in NFL disability benefit evaluations at an October 20 hearing, according to legal reporting updated October 22. The case is Bailey v. The NFL Player Disability & Survivor Benefit Plan.

Beasley Allen, a law firm representing the players, confirmed approval October 21. The firm said the agreement allows affected past claims to be reviewed under race-neutral standards and permanently bars race norming in future evaluations covered by the settlement. It said the plans had told doctors to stop using race-based adjustments in 2021, but earlier claims had not been revisited.

The distinction matters. This case concerns the players’ disability and retirement benefit plans. It should not be confused with the separate NFL concussion settlement, whose race-norming changes received final approval in March 2022.

The plans deny wrongdoing. As summarized in the legal reporting, they say they did not direct independent physicians to use race-based adjustments and had instructed those doctors to stop considering race in June 2021. The settlement is not an admission of liability or a court judgment that the allegations were proved.

The problem hidden inside a baseline

Race norming can sound like a technical detail. In this case, the players’ September 29, 2023, complaint describes why it could have a serious effect. Cognitive tests measure abilities such as memory and thinking. A person’s results are compared with a reference group to help judge whether there has been a decline.

The complaint alleges that race-based comparisons used a lower starting point for Black players. That could make an impairment look smaller and make it harder to qualify for the same benefits. Former players Stacey Bailey and Eric Curry alleged that this process left them receiving less than they should. These are the plaintiffs’ claims, not findings from a trial.

My objection to that approach is straightforward. A person’s race should not become a shortcut for deciding how much ability the person had to lose. A careful evaluation should be able to explain its assumptions. It should also be open to challenge when those assumptions put people at a disadvantage.

I do not want a system that looks at a Black man and quietly expects less from him. I want a system that takes his individual life, condition and evidence seriously.

AI-generated illustration of an older Black man and a woman reviewing a folder together.
A symbolic benefits-review conversation with fictional people, not actual players or case participants. AI-generated artwork by OpenAI for the Utica Phoenix.

A fair review must reach the people waiting

The reported settlement calls for eligible past tests dating to January 1, 2012, to be rescored. If that review leads to a new or higher benefit, retroactive payments carry 6 percent simple annual interest. The reported terms also protect existing benefits from being reduced through this rescoring process. They do not promise that every review will result in a larger payment.

Those limits should be stated plainly. A headline about a settlement can sound as if everyone has received a check. A review process still has to do its work. Families should be able to understand which records are being reviewed, what happens next and whom they can contact with a question.

In my view, meaningful follow-through would include a clear schedule, notices that people can understand and updates on how many reviews have been finished. Any public progress report should protect medical privacy. It can still show whether the promised work is moving.

That is a reasonable test for any institution announcing a correction. How many people were reached? Were missing records addressed? Were people told the result and the reason? A process that cannot answer those questions leaves too much power on one side of the desk.

Listen to players who raised objections

More than 100 former players objected before approval, NBC Sports reported September 30.

The fact that a court approved the deal does not make those concerns unworthy of attention. Nor does an objection, by itself, prove the settlement is a failure. People whose health and income are at stake have good reason to ask hard questions about any agreement that affects them.

We should resist the urge to divide them into grateful winners and difficult critics. The better question is whether they receive a clear explanation of their rights and the result of their review. If a person remains confused, the response should be an answer, not a demand for gratitude.

What this means beyond football

Readers in Utica do not need an NFL career to understand the concern. A benefits decision can be written in language that is hard to follow. A family may understand that the outcome matters without understanding how the system reached it. Institutions should not mistake that gap in knowledge for a lack of intelligence or effort.

I am not suggesting that this football case proves wrongdoing by any local hospital, employer or benefit plan. It does not. I am saying that it gives every institution a useful question to ask: Are we treating each person as an individual, and can we explain the rules we use?

For me, growing older makes that question more urgent. Dignity should not depend on physical strength, a job title or the ability to argue through a complicated form. People deserve respect when they are working, when they are retired and when they need support.

Fans remember the strength and skill players brought to the field. The same men deserve a careful, fair hearing when they seek disability benefits. Last week’s settlement offers a way to revisit past decisions. Its value will be shown in the work that follows and in the treatment of the people waiting for it.

This is an opinion column. Factual claims are linked to the complaint, a statement from players’ counsel and news reporting. It is not advice about an individual legal or medical claim. Featured illustration: a symbolic football helmet, folder and balanced scales, not a photograph or court exhibit. AI-generated artwork by OpenAI for the Utica Phoenix.

Most Popular